![]() |
|
||
|
Tel: (905) 294-7441 Fax: (905) 294-9305 Toll Free 1-800-387-1002
|
|||
The Cash Back Mortgage- Who is the real winner, you or the lender?
For more than a year, a number of major Canadian institutional mortgage lenders have been offering "cash back" incentives to mortgage borrowers. The usual scenario is 3% of the mortgage back, in cash, upon the closing of the mortgage. The hook is you must take a mortgage for a 5 year term or longer, and you must pay "posted" mortgage rates.
Posted mortgage rates for terms of 5 years or more are usually 1 percentage point higher than the best rates available for an equal term.
In the following example you will see who is the real winner in the Cash Back Mortgage.
Assume the following:
If you have amortization software you can do these calculations yourself, using today's current rates.
Examples:
Option #1
A home buyer borrows $100,000.00 at 7.15% and takes the $3,000 cash back and immediately uses the cash back to pay down the mortgage to $97,000.00. After 5 years the borrower would have made payments totaling $41,304.60, paid a total of $32,829.16 in interest and reduced the principal owing on the mortgage to $88,524.56
Option #2
If on the other hand the borrower dealt with MortgageLand and arranged a mortgage of $100,000.00 at 6.15%, did not get the $3,000.00 cash back and DID NOT PAY DOWN the mortgage, the borrower, after 5 years would have made payments totaling $38,925.00. Paid a total of $28,989.43 and reduced the balance owing on the mortgage to $90,064.43.
Option #3
Many people take Option #1, but take the $3,000.00 cash back and use it to pay closing costs and other expenses and do not use it to pay down the mortgage. They borrow $100,000.00 at 7.15%, after five years they have made payments totaling $42,582.00 and paid a total of $33,844.51 in interest, and reduced the balance owing to only $91,262.51.
Clearly, Option #2 is the winner. Your payments are $2,379.60 less than Option #1, which more than compensates for the $1,539.87 differences between the principal amounts owing.
The real loser is Option #3. They pay $3,657.00 more in payments and owe $1,198.08 more in principal than Option #2. The $3,000 cash back will cost them $1,855.08 over five years.
The situations presented above are only for the first five years of the mortgage. If you want to see the real damage look at the difference in the total amount of interest you would pay over the 25-year amortization for each of the options:
Option #1 $109,809.75
Option #2 $94,833.00
Option #3 $113,208.42
Which option would your banker choose for you? At MortgageLand we tell you the whole truth.
[ GOOD CREDIT DOES NOT NECESSARILY MEAN PERFECT CREDIT ]
Never,Never,Ever Buy Mortgage Life Insurance From the Mortgage Lender!
USING YOUR RRSP FOR HOME PURCHASE
A lender's decision to lend is based on several issues. Can the borrower afford to pay the mortgage payment, taxes and operating costs of a home, plus pay any other debt payments? Does the borrower have a good, long established credit history? Is the borrower's total income adequate and regular? Is there sufficient equity in the property? These are the prime areas of concern to any institutional lender.
CAN THE BORROWER AFFORD THE HOME?
Lenders use a GDS (Gross Debt Service) ratio to determine the home affordability. In essence it is the maximum percentage of the family income that may be used for "shelter payments". GDS is defined as follows:
Total Annual Mortgage Payments +Annual Real Estate Taxes +Annual Heating Costs + (If a condo) Half-Annual Condo Fees. This number is then divided by Total Household Income.
= $15,500 = GDSR = 30.78%
$51,500
Institutional lender's usually allow a maximum percentage of 28% to 32% for the GDSR.
Hand-in-hand with the GDSR is the Total Debt Service Ratio, is the percentage of the total annual family income which can be used for shelter payments plus total annual debt payments.
|
Bob and Mary's TDSR=
|
|
Many home buyers are not fully aware of the "hidden costs" of buying and closing the purchase of a home. Below is a list of, and an approximation of many (not all) the costs you could be required to pay on or before your closing date.
HIGH RATIO (LOW DOWN PAYMENT) MORTGAGES
By law, in Canada, no Bank, Trust Company, Credit Union, or Insurance Company can lend more than 75% of the value of a property, unless that mortgage is insured with mortgage default insurance.
Default insurance is a cost to the borrower and it protects the lender. Should you default on the mortgage at some point in the future and the lender lose money on the sale of the property, Because of a low down payment amount you are deemed to be a higher lending risk. To reduce the risk the lender uses a mortgage default insurance policy issued by one of two companies, Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) an agency of the Federal Government, and GE Capital, an international profit oriented organization. Both companies charge the same rates. They differ only in one matter that impacts the average consumer. See Prepayment Penalties in this section.
Here is an example of how it works:
Bob and Mary purchase a home for $150,000.00 They have $7,500.00 (5% of the purchase price) available for the down payment. That means they need $142,500.00 more to complete the transaction. By using the chart below, you will see that the cost of mortgage default insurance for someone who has a 5% down payment is 3.75% of the mortgage amount, in this case $5,343.75.
The mortgage lender then adds this amount $5,343.75 to the $142,500.00 for a total mortgage of $147,843.75. This is the amount that will be used to calculate your mortgage payments. On the closing day, the lender will send a cheque to your lawyer for the $142,500.00(less any adjustments), and a cheque for $5,343.75 to the mortgage default insurance company.
Down Payment as % ..............Cost of Default Insurance as %
Of Purchase Price ...................of amount Borrowed (Premium)
If the mortgage is to be advanced in multiple draws e.g. to fund construction of a house or "purchase plus improvements", then add 0.75% to the cost of default insurance.
Just as an appraiser gives an independent opinion as to the market value of your home, a qualified home inspector gives the home buyer an unemotional, independent rating of the physical building.
A good home inspector will encourage you to join them in the inspection, from basement to the roof, inside and outside.
You should receive a written evaluation report stating the age, condition and estimated remaining life of the various systems that make up a house. Estimates of costs to replace or repair defects should be included in the report.
The home inspector can not make old items new. If the furnace in your 20-year-old house is the original furnace, then he will likely tell you that it has a remaining "life expectancy" of 5 years or even suggest replacing it sooner.
There are a variety of professionally designated home inspectors. Ask friends who have recently purchased a home, local lawyers and mortgage companies, for a referral. Ask for the inspector's educational and professional background. Most importantly ask for proof of professional liability insurance and a list of at least five references.
All mortgages are legal contracts binding the lender and the borrower to specific terms for a specific length of time. A lender is not obligated to "open" a mortgage; there are some legislated exceptions. If the borrower wishes to "break" the mortgage contract before the contact expires, and the lender allows the "breakage", then most lenders will charge some form of prepayment penalty.
There is no "standard" mortgage penalty. Each lender draws their specific contract which lays out the duties of both the borrower and the lender, if and when the mortgage is open, and costs of any prepayment privilege. This contract is called the "standard charge terms". Unfortunately most borrowers do not see this document until they go to their lawyer's office to sign the documents.
Most major lenders (not all) have a prepayment penalty "equal to, the greater of a) three months interest or b) the interest differential".
As mortgage interest on most Canadian mortgages is calculated "semi-annually, not in advance", you would require a set of tables of mortgage interest factors or a financial calculator to determine the correct amount.
If your mortgage was originally a CMHC insured mortgage, and it is more than three years old, the maximum penalty is three months interest. If your mortgage was originally a GE Capital insured mortgage the penalty is whatever is indicated in the standard charge terms.